The Confederation of Guernsey Industry has called on Deputies to ensure that any package of tax reforms strikes the right balance between raising additional revenue, improving public sector efficiency and supporting long-term economic growth.
Ahead of the forthcoming debate, the CGi continues to maintain that income tax should form a central part of addressing the Island’s structural fiscal deficit, alongside reductions in spending and measures to stimulate growth in the economy. It also proposes increases in company registration fees, corporate taxation and the introduction of deferred pensions as part of a broader package of fiscal measures.
Garin Dart, CGi chair, said: “Deputy Parkinson advised the CGi in May that a 1% increase in the rate of income tax would raise £5 million annually. Had this been increased by 3% three years ago, cumulative additional revenue by 2026 would have reached £45 million and made a significant contribution to narrowing the funding gap.
“Income tax alone is unlikely to address every aspect of the Island’s funding challenges. It remains, however, an effective and straightforward mechanism. The collection systems already exist, changes can be implemented quickly and rates adjusted without creating an entirely new tax administration.
“I also wanted to emphasise that our views are also not aligned with recent public statements made by other local groups, suggesting that all businesses support the GST proposals.”
While the debate has largely focused on whether GST should be introduced, the CGi’s concern is how the tax would operate in practice. It questioned whether the Revenue Service, which continues to manage significant backlogs, has the capacity to administer an entirely new tax regime.
Mr Dart added: “This is the perfect storm. Given the challenges and cost overruns experienced with projects such as MyGov, Agilisys and the redevelopment of the PEH, Islanders would inevitably question the States’ ability to deliver another major infrastructure system at this time.”
The CGi also pointed to research commissioned by Henley Business School in 2014, which concluded that GST was likely to have a disproportionately negative impact on key sectors within Guernsey’s economy and would be regressive, affecting lower-income households most significantly. The report can be viewed here
“If GST is introduced, it should be accompanied by measures that encourage investment, strengthen consumer confidence and stimulate economic growth. We also believe expenditure restraint should precede any new taxation wherever possible,” said Mr Dart.